Architecture · Conservation · Historic House Museums · Merchant's House · Museums · Pennsylvania Station · Preservation

The Good Guys Won This One!

The Merchant’s House Museum, showing the original Duncan Phyfe chairs. The carpet and window treatment are exact reproductions of what was in the house in 1850.

The City Council Came Through!

This week the New York City Council voted unanimously to deny a developer an application to build an eight-story hotel next door to one of New York’s treasures: the Merchant’s House Museum, a 186-year old house, a family home with original furnishings and objects now open to the public. The proposed construction threatened the fragile building with catastrophic damage and a possible collapse.

There will always be a conflict.

There are those who want to want to preserve historic buildings and those who want to demolish them for various reasons, sometimes because it is prohibitively expensive or impossible to save them, but often for selfish financial reasons, or simply because they assume that whatever is new is better than what is old.
Original Pennsylvania Station interior.

In 1963, when Pennsylvania Station, a beautiful monumental example of Beaux Arts architecture, was demolished, many New Yorkers raised a loud hew and cry in opposition. Penn Station could have been saved, but the good guys who wanted to “renovate not amputate” lost that one. Today, 55 years later, New Yorkers, especially those whose daily commute takes them through the miserable underground replacement sorely lament that decision.

The argument against demolishing Penn Station was primarily based on its architectural significance.

But I think an even more important reason for saving a historic building is that its presence in the community connects us to the past. We need to be reminded as we go about our daily lives that the present is not all there is, that we are not the end-all and be-all, that in many ways we owe who we are to what went on before we existed.

The connection is not always conscious, but it exists nevertheless—like background music you don’t particularly notice but that affects your mood. A city with no old buildings would be an Orwellian nightmare.


18.a rear bedroom
The rear bedroom of the Merchant’s House with its original furniture.

The place where we can most easily connect to life beyond memory is a domestic space.

Here is where people actually ate their dinners, entertained their friends, climbed the stairs to bed. These places are rare and rarer still are those that still contain the furniture and personal possession of the family that lived there,

Those who know me and have heard me repeat the “really real table” story more often than they wanted may now skip the following two paragraphs.

 I was giving a tour of the house to second graders. The children were seated on the parlor carpet in front of me. I explained that a family with eight children lived in the house over 100 years ago and today the house was still here, just as it had been then. The furniture was theirs; the big sister played the piano; the family sat on the chairs.

 A hand shot into the air. The seven-year-old’s eyes were wide. He pointed to the center table. “You mean . . . you mean . . . that’s the really real table?”

This little boy “got it.”

He obviously realized that there were those who came before him and were no longer here, and in that moment he had connected to them. Caught up with our personal ambitions, we sometimes forget that we too will pass into history and someday other youngsters will judge us and find our homes and habits and possessions quaint and queer. The historic home serves to remind us of this humbling fact.

So thanks, City Council, and all those who worked so hard to convince them that the Merchant’s House is worth saving!

The Really Real Table

For more about the Merchant’s House see An Old Merchant’s House and the sequel, Miracle on Fourth Steet by me. You can read more about these books here.

8 thoughts on “The Good Guys Won This One!

  1. Dear Mary: I’m so happy to hear the exciting news about the Merchant’s House! Sometimes the underdog DOES WIN. I truly believe in saving historic structures for future generations to learn from and enjoy. Just a few blocks from my apartment, the historic Poe home (on W 3rd Street) and the legendary Provincetown Playhouse (where Bette Davis and playwright Eugene O’Neill got their start) were demolished or dramatically altered by the ever expanding New York University. Their argument was that records failed to prove that Poe ever lived in the row house they wanted to demolish. And demolish they did. Now a “replica” stands in its place. As for the Provincetown Playhouse, it was “gutted” and only the original facade remains. All this was done in the name of “progress.” I grumble each time I walk by the Provincetown Playhouse. The only consolation is that a portion of the original playhouse building is still used for live performances. However, I heard that most of the interior of the building was gutted and converted into classrooms. The grand old lady (The Merchant’s House) refused to be removed from her proper place. Thank goodness. Do you think Gertrude’s spirit had anything to do with saving the old place? Maybe we should save that conversation for Halloween~


    1. And so it goes! It’s too bad there has to be so much effort and expenditure to fight to save historic sites. But where there is enough money to put up a good fight and friends can be mobilized, it can turn out for the best. Not always, however.


  2. And when you wish on a star….. the “really real ‘Old Lady” on Fourth Street. So many thanks to The City Council and all those in support, and special thanks to you Mary, for superbly telling us her story.


  3. We have been following the threat to the Merchant’s House with trepidation and are so relieved at the outcome!


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.