Education · Handwriting

The Cursive Handwriting Debate is Not Over—Not Yet!

ballpointpen_(1)_360_360_90Yesterday I received two handwritten missives in my mail, both written in cursive. One was from my doctor, explaining the results of recent routine blood tests and wishing me a pleasant weekend. The other, a brief and lovely message from a friend who recently visited, thanking me for a pleasant time.

And not too long ago, I had a lively conversation with a stranger on the bus who happened to notice I was doing some editing with a fountain pen. He allowed that he loved writing with fountain pens, in fact collected them. I was sorry when we came to his stop.

Personal experience aside— it seems to me that resistance to abandoning the teaching of cursive handwriting is growing.

Some teachers say that in this technological era, being able to write in cursive is an unnecessary skill.  What kids are going to need in the future is skill in keyboarding, and they don’t have time to spend on teaching both handwriting and keyboarding. That’s the good reason they give for their opposition. I suspect the real reason is that the better kids are at keyboarding, the better they will do on the tests that are mandated by the common core. In some school districts, children as young as eight years old have to be able to drag and drop and type answers on a keyboard so that they can take tests mandated by the core—tests that as far as I can see benefit no one except the those involved in the test industry. Certainly they don’t benefit the third grader who has squirmed and struggled answering questions that are widely seen as too difficult.

Another real reason is that many teachers themselves do not write in cursive and so feel unable to teach it.

Unfortunately proponents do not put forth very strong arguments. One of their favorites is that if kids can’t read cursive, they won’t be able to read our founding documents. Who in the world reads founding documents in the original copperplate? Have you ever? Neither have I; neither have those making this argument. If that were the primary reason kids need to learn to write cursive, proponents of teaching it would lose hands down.

The strongest arguments for teaching of cursive comes from neurological research. And these are powerful arguments. Pity they are not advanced more often.

 

3 thoughts on “The Cursive Handwriting Debate is Not Over—Not Yet!

  1. Agee with this 100%. How do I memorize lines and lyrics? I write them in long hand in a notebook. If the show is hard…I do it everyday. There is something magic about putting pen to paper.

    Like

    1. It absolutely does seem magical the way thoughts and language can be transferred fluently and rapidly to the page without any thought given to how you are doing it. (After you learn how to do it well, of course).

      Like

  2. I am so pleased when my 8 year. old granddaughter makes her own greeting cards for me and writes her loving message in beautifully written script, which thankfully is still being taught in her public school. If teaching cursive is no longer being considered a necessary part of school curriculum, I wonder about the many times one is required to give even a signature to documents, checks, etc. It pleases me, when in doing so, I am often complimented on my beautiful handwriting, leading me to think that already it is unusual to see cursive writing these days, much less that which is legible and written with care. I admire so the beautiful cursive writing that prevailed during the nineteenth century that occasionally is on display at the Merchant’s House Museum. It has become yet another lost art !

    Like

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.